“What did Xiaoyue'er mean by what she was doing just now...?”
My heart was pounding. I swallowed and forced myself to calm down. The scissors in Xiaoyue'er's hand wavered as if she were aiming at some part of me, and the sight made me terribly nervous.
What was going on? Was Xiaoyue'er a yandere too? Why was she holding scissors, and why had what she just said sounded so strange...?
“When Dad was with that girl just now, you two were so close, weren’t you? You fed her and hugged her. She had long black hair and was really pretty.”
“That was Xianxian. Xiaoyue'er should know that...”
“I know. I know Dad seems to care about her more than he cares about me.”
With a click, Xiaoyue'er locked the door. I held my breath as she slowly came closer, then climbed onto the bed.
“Dad, aren’t you going to lie down?”
“I’ll lie down...”
If I did as she asked, I could already guess what would happen next. But Xiaoyue'er was clearly not herself right now, and if I refused, something even more troublesome might happen.
I obediently lay down. Xiaoyue'er moved too, straddling my waist. The little girl smelled sweet, and her small body was soft and seemed almost weightless.
But my whole body was tense. Not for any other reason than that Xiaoyue'er still had the scissors in her hand, drawing circles over my chest.
“All right, Dad. You can explain now. Why were you so close to her just now? Even if she’s your daughter, shouldn’t she be punished when she does something wrong?”
“Punished...?”
“She talked back to Dad just now, didn’t she?”
Xiaoyue'er looked as if it were only natural. “And Dad didn’t do anything wrong. So she was the one at fault. But why was Dad so gentle with her? You say we’re both your daughters, but Xiaoyue'er finds that a little hard to believe...”
“Y-You don’t believe me...? I mean, what other relationship could we possibly have besides being your daughters?”
I could only smile wryly. I thought of the little girls as younger sisters, since I wasn’t old enough to be their father. But the fact that they were all my daughters couldn’t be changed.
“Then let me ask you, Dad. She was the one who did something wrong just now, right? Xiaoyue'er was the one who did the right thing, right? She talked back to Dad and said something really awful, so she was wrong. Xiaoyue'er pointed it out to her and argued against her, correcting her mistake. That was the right thing to do, wasn’t it? But...”
“But...”
Xiaoyue'er lifted her eyes. Her silver-white hair swayed gently, and her voice held a chill.
“The person who did something wrong wasn’t punished. She was rewarded instead. Dad being so close to her proves it. You hugged her and fed her, while you pushed me away... So does that mean Dad encourages people to do wrong? Then Xiaoyue'er will do something wrong too. If doing the right thing means Dad will distance himself from me...”
“N-No, that’s not it...”
Xiaoyue'er seemed lost in thought. At last, I found a chance to speak. I first took the scissors from the little girl’s hand. Xiaoyue'er didn’t resist and let me take them. I finally breathed a sigh of relief, and could properly explain myself.
“That’s not it. What I did just now wasn’t a reward... It was comfort. Xiaoyue'er, you’re right that Xianxian did something wrong. But we shouldn’t punish someone every single time they make a mistake, should we? That wouldn’t do any good. Xianxian was upset just now, so I was comforting her. She also realized she was wrong and apologized to me on her own.”
“See? Isn’t that a good way to handle it? Xianxian understood her mistake, and I didn’t go too far in dealing with it. That’s better for both of us.”
“Xiaoyue'er doesn’t think so.”
She immediately contradicted me, her voice entirely devoid of emotion.
“When you do something wrong, being scolded is the right thing. Dad didn’t scold her simply because he didn’t want to. That’s a subjective judgment. He only did that because he likes her so much that he’s willing to play favorites... I did the right thing, but Dad pushed me away. The person who did wrong got close to Dad instead. Xiaoyue'er really can’t accept that. Why is it like this, Dad?”
“It really isn’t like that... Xianxian and Xiaoyue'er are equally important to me, okay? I only met you today, but I can swear I’m not playing favorites.”
“Dad says all the right things, but his actions don’t match.”
I smiled wryly. It seemed no matter how much I explained, it wouldn’t help. Xiaoyue'er was convinced I was playing favorites, and I had no way to argue back. Judging by what I’d just done, she wasn’t wrong.
Xiaoyue'er had clearly stood up for me, but I’d taken Xianxian’s side. Anyone would be hurt by that... Though it seemed she was past being merely hurt. She was starting to seem a little... yandere.
“...I was wrong. I’m sorry, Xiaoyue'er. Is that okay?”
“Dad’s apologizing to me? Why?”
Though she was still sulking, she didn’t refuse when I hugged her. The little girl rested lightly against my chest and looked up at me. Her long silver hair spilled around her, and her clear, transparent red eyes gazed at me, as if they could see my reflection.
“Mm. I was wrong just now, so I’m apologizing to Xiaoyue'er... I’m really sorry. I should’ve explained things to you first, but I waited for you to bring it up. And I didn’t admit I was wrong at the start, either. It was all my fault. Please don’t be angry, okay?”
“...I’m not angry with you, Dad.”
Her clear, transparent red eyes stayed fixed on me. After a long while, she shook her head and answered.
“There’s a difference between right and wrong. But no matter what Dad does, Xiaoyue'er will think it’s right. I don’t think Dad can’t do that. Dad can do whatever he wants... It’s just that Dad is too nice to other people, and that makes me unhappy.”
“I-Is that so...?”
After such a sincere apology, I was suddenly a little stunned. I’d thought Xiaoyue'er was angry with me, but it seemed she was upset about Xianxian?
Xiaoyue'er stared intently at me. “If I do something wrong, I’ll apologize to Dad, and I’ll accept my punishment. But if I do the right thing, then Dad has to reward me too... If things are out of balance, Xiaoyue'er won’t keep doing the right thing forever, you know? What matters most to Xiaoyue'er is Dad’s affection. Do you understand?”
“I understand.”
She seemed to care about being fair and objective, but when it came to me, her sense of fairness became completely warped. That was the impression Xiaoyue'er gave.
“So Dad still hasn’t given me today’s reward.”
“All right, I understand. What reward does Xiaoyue'er want...?”
“Dad has to let me sleep here tonight.”
The little girl rolled onto the bed and wrapped her arms around mine. When she curled up, her tiny body looked shorter than my arm.
“Also, Dad has to take me to school tomorrow. You have to carry me in your arms at breakfast and feed me, too. But most importantly, I want a good-morning kiss and a good-night kiss every day.”
As Xiaoyue'er spoke, she pointed to her cheek. I could only smile helplessly. I didn’t know how long this kind of life could last. I’d probably wake up from this dream before long, and if so, I didn’t mind.
“All right, then. I’ll agree to everything, Xiaoyue'er.”
“Then hurry up and give me tonight’s good-night kiss, Dad. Both cheeks, okay...?”